Review Schview

Collated critic reviews and ratings of Hindi movies.

  • Pankh

    Cast:

    Maradona Rebello, Lilette Dubey, Bipasha Basu

    Director:

    Sudipto Chattopadhyaya

    35

    Overall rating based on
    15 reviews

  • ...is fiercely individualistic cinema. Those who support for edgy, mind-pubbing cinema, should check it out immediately…

    Khalid Mohammed

    PassionforCinema

    Full review »

    79

    Critic rating

  • ..is really not a film for the feeble. The director sets out to shock, scandalise, repulse and disgust you. If you are prepared for this then take a chance.

    Preeti Arora

    Rediff

    Full review »

    49

    Critic rating

  • ...is frankly ugly and beyond a point, absolutely tedious. Sanjay and Sudipto want to be edgy and dark but the writing isn’t sophisticated enough to support their ambitions.

    Anupama Chopra

    NDTV

    Full review »

    39

    Critic rating

  • ...despite of earnest efforts from the cast members, including Bipasha Basu, fails to impress...

    K K Rai

    Stardust

    Full review »

    39

    Critic rating

  • Disturbing abstract stuff. The entire film feels like one huge hallucination. Even if you are ready to take the flight of fancy with a boy who's seriously troubled because his mom made him play girl-roles in films when he was young, it won't be a fun ride at all.

    Meeta Kabra

    WOGMA

    Full review »

    39

    Critic rating

  • ...the film has an intriguing story but leaves you confused.

    NA

    IBNLive

    Full review »

    39

    Critic rating

  • Too surrealistic, too unfocussed, this gender-bender tale engages, but only in bits and parts.

    Nikhat Kazmi

    The Times of India

    Full review »

    39

    Critic rating

  • The film has an interesting premise, but it hasn’t been fleshed out satisfactorily.

    Sonia Chopra

    Sify

    Full review »

    39

    Critic rating

  • ...do not have any entertainment value and it could not be completely passed as an art film. Works in bits but not for the faint hearted.

    Ashok Nayak

    Now Running

    Full review »

    29

    Critic rating

  • ...is a like a caterpillar who refuses to become a butterfly.

    Tushar Joshi

    MidDay

    Full review »

    29

    Critic rating

  • The film picks up the important and delicate issue of gender confusion and sexual identity, but treats the story in such a pretentious and heavy-handed manner that it's sometimes hard to empathize with the protagonist's pain.

    Rajeev Masand

    IBNLive

    Full review »

    29

    Critic rating

  • Precious raw stock, precious time and precious resources are being utilised to create movies which are so weird that only its creator would know what he's actually trying to say. PANKH is one of those films, which, frankly, makes no sense.

    Taran Adarsh

    Bollywood Hungama

    Full review »

    19

    Critic rating

  • ...is bold and in-your-face alright, but very, very crude.

    Martin D'Souza

    Glamsham

    Full review »

    19

    Critic rating

  • The execution lets down the film, peppered by gratuitously grungy dialogue ( a liberal use of the `f’ word is just the start of it; all kinds of invective jostle for attention, especially because they are blipped out), and a series of unlovely people.

    Shubhra Gupta

    Indian Express

    Full review »

    19

    Critic rating

  • ...it's a subject that should be spoken about. But a sensational and titillating approach doesn’t seem credible.

    Dhruvi Shah

    Filmfare

    Full review »

    19

    Critic rating

FAQ / Contact / RSS Feed

A Chugs Designs Project

Umm...